Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

United States

The Supreme Court Confirmation Hearing as ‘Ideological Food Fight’

Professor Ringhand broadly agreed. “The hearings are at their best when senators ask real questions about law, and nominees take the opportunity to explain their perspectives,” she said. “We have seen flashes of this, such as when Judge Jackson talks about her judicial methodology, or her work with the sentencing guidelines.”

But the Jackson hearings lacked a theme, Professor Collins said.

“Things got pretty strange at times,” he said. Among the questions posed to Judge Jackson were ones from Senator Ted Cruz, Republican of Texas, about children’s books, from Senator Marsha Blackburn, Republican of Tennessee, about how to define the word “woman” and from Senator Lindsey Graham, Republican of South Carolina, about how faithful she was on a numerical scale.

“The Republicans did seem to coalesce around three main themes over the course of the hearings: that Judge Jackson is soft on crime, that she has an underdeveloped judicial philosophy and that she is the product of a left-wing dark-money campaign to get her on the bench,” Professor Collins said.

Supreme Court nominations are committed to the political branches of the government, meaning they are political by constitutional design. But politics used to be subtext, not front and center.

Partisanship in confirmation hearings can only hurt the Supreme Court’s authority and legitimacy, Chief Justice Roberts said in 2016.

“When you have a sharply political, divisive hearing process, it increases the danger that whoever comes out of it will be viewed in those terms,” he said. “If the Democrats and Republicans have been fighting so fiercely about whether you’re going to be confirmed, it’s natural for some member of the public to think, well, you must be identified in a particular way as a result of that process.”

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

You May Also Like


The Pennsylvania Board of Pardons (BOP) secretary appointed by the state’s lieutenant governor and Democratic Senate candidate John Fetterman repeatedly tweeted to “disarm the police” and advocated for...


After a federal judge gave the Justice Department a deadline to determine whether former President Donald Trump supports or opposes unsealing the search warrant...


Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer, D-N.Y., dodged a question on whether he believes President Biden should run in 2024. Schumer said he was “not...

United States

As remarkable as it was for the Justice Department to ask a federal judge on Thursday to unseal the warrant it used this week...


A Mexican illegal immigrant who entered the U.S. earlier this year has been convicted of being in possession of child pornography — including images...


Press play to listen to this article LONDON — It’s a long-held maxim in British politics that divided parties do not win elections. And so...

United States

WASHINGTON— After four years of President Donald J. Trump’s raging against his intelligence services, posting classified information to Twitter and announcing that he took...


Democrats are moving to defend a proposed expansion of the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) under the Inflation Reduction Act, claiming that the increase in...