Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?


Manchin-Schumer bill on glide path in House; obstacles remain given Democrats’ disunity

The $739 billion tax increase, climate change and health care bill agreed to by Sen. Joe Manchin and Majority Leader Chuck Schumer is on a glide path toward passage in the House, but divisions between progressive and moderate Democrats remain an obstacle. 

Because Democrats hold a slight 220-210 majority in the House, Speaker Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif, can withstand only four Democratic defectors when the entire chamber is voting, given likely unanimous GOP opposition. 

The slim cushion means Pelosi needs just about every Democrat to vote in favor of the Manchin-Schumer bill when it comes up for an expected vote Friday.

That reality has mobilized outside groups with a vested interest in seeing the bill fail. 


The health care and pharmaceutical industries, in particular, are working hard to pressure moderate House Democrats into opposing the bill. 

Health care lobbyists are targeting Democrats representing swing districts or moderates who are retiring or have lost their primaries. The argument is largely focused on selling lawmakers that the bill will adversely impact seniors, a core voting block for both Democrats and Republicans. 

“Health plans and drugmakers are going to have to navigate more government in Medicare Part D, and they are concerned this will mean fewer benefits and care for our seniors,” said a source familiar with the health care industry and its lobbying efforts and messaging. “Not to mention, seniors will now be facing higher premiums during historic inflation.” 

Topping the list of targets is a cadre of moderate House Democrats who previously raised concerns about allowing Medicare to negotiate the price of prescription drugs, a central provision of the Manchin-Schumer bill. 

Sen. Joe Manchin, D-W.Va., speaks to reporters outside a U.S. Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee hearing on Capitol Hill in Washington July 19, 2022. 

The pressure campaign does not appear to be making significant progress, however. 

Rep. Kurt Schrader, an Oregon Democrat and target of the efforts, threw his support behind the legislation Monday. Schrader, who is retiring after losing to a more progressive primary challenger, was seen as a key holdout since he had voiced apprehensions about the prescription drug pricing plan. 

“The Inflation Reduction Act will reduce the deficit by hundreds of billions of dollars while lowering prescription drug costs for American families and strengthening health care,” Schrader and other members of the moderate Blue Dog Coalition said in a joint statement. “We remain laser-focused on solving our nation’s major economic, energy and climate problems for future generations and will move swiftly to send this bill to the president’s desk.”

Rep. Kurt Schrader, D-Ore., speaks during a news conference in Washington July 24, 2019. 

Outside of prescription drugs, two moderate Texas Democrats are also facing pressure to oppose the bill over its inclusion of a fee on methane emissions. 

The tax is seen as particularly burdensome to fossil fuel industries that employ thousands of workers in the border region between Texas and Mexico. 


Apart from moderates, support for the Manchin-Schumer bill is also not a given from the Democratic Party’s progressive faction. 

While most far-left lawmakers are expected to back the legislation, some have criticized it for being too friendly to the fossil fuel industry. 

Sen. Bernie Sanders, I-Vt., lambasted the bill last week during a marathon voting session as not going far enough to combat climate change. 

Senator Joe Manchin I Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer

“This bill, as currently written, includes a huge giveaway to the fossil fuel industry,” Sanders said. “It’s a slap in the face to the communities fighting to protect themselves from filthy fossil fuels.”

Sanders eventually wound up voting for the bill after his attempts to have it amended to prevent subsidies from going to energy companies were defeated. The Vermont independent’s progressive allies in the House, however, are significantly more hard-line. 

Last year, six far-left House Democrats nearly tanked President Biden’s bipartisan infrastructure bill over climate concerns. The bill would have failed in the House if not for the support of 13 moderate Republicans. 

GOP leaders have made clear that Pelosi can expect no such help on the Manchin-Schumer bill. 

“House Republicans will stand up against this tax on American families and will be opposing this bill,” said GOP Whip Steve Scalise, R-La. 

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

You May Also Like


Georgia Gov. Brian Kemp on Sunday refused to say whether he will campaign with former President Donald Trump if the fellow Republican chooses to...


The presidents of nine NATO countries in central and eastern Europe declared on Sunday that they would never recognize the annexation by Russia of...


While federal and state officials continue to respond to the damage from Hurricane Ian, FEMA Administrator Deanne Criswell defended officials in Lee County, Florida,...


Crime is on the rise in major cities across the country and many Republicans seeking election to the Senate have put the issue at...


Supporters of a coup against Burkina Faso leader Paul-Henri Sandaogo Damiba attacked the French embassy in the capital Ouagadougou on Sunday. Security forces used...


Several instances of political violence, many with victims supporting conservative causes, have occurred since President Biden warned of the threat supporters of former President...


Press play to listen to this article Splits in the governing U.K. Conservative Party burst into the open Sunday as senior Tory Michael Gove...


Virginia Gov. Glenn Youngkin’s cross-country campaign tour on behalf of fellow Republicans running in November’s elections resumes this week, with a stop Wednesday in...