Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?


Jackson cites Scalia and Barrett as she navigates GOP senators’ written questions

Jackson’s responses to the questions — which were put to her in writing after her marathon session of live Senate testimony last week — were posted Friday, ahead of Monday’s scheduled committee vote to advance her nomination.

Repeatedly, Jackson referenced comments made by conservative Justice Amy Coney Barrett to navigate Republican questions touching on abortion and efforts to expand the Supreme Court.

To explain why she didn’t answer during the hearing Louisiana Sen. John Kennedy’s question about when certain constitutional protections begin to cover an “unborn child,” Jackson quoted Barrett in her written responses: “I will apply the law fully and faithfully. I will not impose my religious convictions or personal beliefs on anyone.”

Elsewhere, Jackson invoked the late Justice Antonin Scalia, a legal lodestar for Republicans, to ground her approach to the law.

Asked by Iowa Sen. Chuck Grassley about the language she used in one prominent case as a district court judge where she declared that “Presidents are not kings” as she ruled against the Trump administration, Jackson pointed to Scalia to defend her rhetorical style.

“Clear writing is key to a transparent judiciary and public confidence in courts. I therefore have at times used imagery, allegories, or metaphors to explain complicated legal arguments,” she wrote. “This is consistent with the practices of many other judges and justices, including Justice Antonin Scalia.”

The responses posted Friday did not include any questions from committee Democrats. The 240 written questions that Texas Sen. Ted Cruz posed for the judge also came with six paragraphs of instructions for how she should approach answering his inquiries; his directive that she not cross-reference answers provided in other questions was ignored.

Several of the Republicans’ questions asked her to dissect rulings she issued. Other responses tread back over ground covered in her hearings about her judicial approach and her views on precedent.

Some senators asked her to weigh in on media reports about her nomination process, inquiring about the PR professionals she enlisted while she was being considered for the vacancy (Jackson said she didn’t hire anyone, but that consultant helped her friends manage press requests) and about the former clerk who edited the Wikipedia pages of the other contenders for the seat (she said that she was unaware the ex-clerk was making those edits before it was reported.).

Several more questions hit the culture war beats that Republicans have emphasized as they’ve sought to shape her nomination fight around the issues they think will resonate in the midterms. She faced a half-dozen questions about critical race theory.

Watch the key moments from the Ketanji Brown Jackson confirmation hearing

“Academic theories have played no role in my judicial decision-making,” she said in response to one such inquiry, from Arkansas Sen. Tom Cotton.

Multiple written questions revisited her refusal during her live testimony to provide Tennessee Sen. Marsha Blackburn with a definition of a “woman.”

“I am aware that the reason these questions are being posed to me is because there are active conversations happening in the public sphere — among policymakers and others — regarding LGBTQ individuals, especially transgender individuals, and their participation in various activities,” Jackson wrote in her written response, while noting that previous Supreme Court nominees were not asked such questions. “This is precisely why I, as a federal judge and as a nominee, must decline to answer these questions.”

She added, however, that she was “pleased to be the sixth woman nominated to serve on the Supreme Court.”

CNN’s Ariane de Vogue contributed to this report.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

You May Also Like


The President said last week during a trip to Buffalo, New York, after a mass shooting took place at a grocery store there that...


In a four-page order, the court found that a lower court “properly rejected appellants’ arguments that the subpoenas issued by the OAG should be...


“Cain killed Abel and that’s a problem that we have. What we need to do is look into how we can stop those things....


The committee subpoenaed Perry and Biggs along with House Minority Leader Kevin McCarthy, Reps. Mo Brooks of Alabama and Jim Jordan of Ohio earlier...


“I don’t take my platform lightly. I’m not perfect, I’m human. I have things that I walk through. That’s why I feel like people...


“America would not exist without the heroism of the young adults who fought and died in our revolutionary arm,” wrote Judge Ryan Nelson, who...


The NRA is the highly politicized body that spent decades radicalizing the GOP on guns and tearing down moderate firearm laws, resulting in a...


The justices issued a one-line order and there were no noted dissents. It is used in federal rules that regulate carbon emissions, or in...